I now blog over at The Eyre Guide! This blog is an archive of my past posts.

Friday, February 22, 2013

Review: Sherlock Holmes: The Rediscovered Railway and Other Stories

Posted by Charlene // Tags: , ,
Sherlock Holmes: The Rediscovered Railway and Other Stories
by John Taylor

Plot Summary:

Four more thrilling Sherlock Holmes adventures from John Taylor, the creator of The Unopened Casebook of Sherlock Holmes , inspired by the original stories of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Includes An Inscrutable Masquerade ; The Conundrum of Coach 13 ; The Trinity Vicarage Larceny ; and The 10:59 Assassin.


Some new Sherlock Holmes stories read by Benedict Cumberbatch?  Yes, please.  Honestly that is the only reason I picked up this audiobook, but I'm glad that I did because not only did I really enjoy Benedict's reading (wonderfully varied and distinct and his Sherlock is appropriately different from his modern TV version), I really enjoyed these stories.

"An Inscrutable Masquerade" was my favorite actually, Watson is kept largely in the dark, as Holmes works on the case, and I found Watson's repressed exasperation yet general good will to honor Holmes' difficult requests so endearing and a perfect representation of his character.  The mystery itself was not too difficult to unravel, but the crafting of the story was very entertaining.

"The Conundrum of Coach 13" was a bit drawn out, probably because I think it is easy to guess how the crime was engineered.  The 'who' was not as easy to figure out, and it was a fun twist. And nice to hear Benedict do an American accent!

"The Trinity Vicarage Larceny" was the weakest story in my opinion.  More of a character driven mystery in a small town village.  It was only okay for me.

"The 10:59 Assassin" was a good end to this set of stories because the nature of the mystery was so convoluted and full of red herrings.  Definitely this was a more mind twisty mystery, with a very memorable set-up.

Of course these stories don't match the original in cleverness, but it does a believable job of capturing the characters and creating some very interesting mysteries.  It's an enjoyable listen and worth it if you are a fan of Holmes or Benedict.

Share this post: Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Email This Pin This Share on Google Plus Share on Tumblr
Scroll Up


  1. Of course I am a HUGE fan of Holmes and Watson. I love there clever stories, so I think that I might like this one a lot.
    GREAT review!
    Your reader,

    1. I think this is an enjoyable listen for the fans, so I hope you do get to check it out! Thanks for stopping by!

  2. You had me at Benedict Cumberbatch!

    1. LOL, he makes picking which audiobook to listen to so easy!

  3. I hadn't heard of this release before - it sounds pretty neat. I'll have to seek out a copy! :)