I've moved bookishwhimsy.com to tumblr! This blog is now an archive of my past posts.


Friday, October 11, 2013

The Journey Home - First Week Discussion

Posted by Charlene // Tags: , ,

Prologue - Chapter 16 
General First Impressions of Finnikin of the Rock


When I first read this book I remembered thinking what a lot of story threads from the past are sprinkled throughout - what happened when Finnikin watched them burn Seranonna, what happened to the Monts, to the novices, Trevanion and Beatriss, and to the Guard, etc.  The picture is never really clear until the end, of everything that happened in the past and the non-linear way in which this story is told can be a bit overwhelming.  Reading it a second time really helped me order the events in my mind (and it's especially interesting to compare it to what's to come in the next two books).  Of course I am yet again in awe of Melina Marchetta's storytelling because despite the clear, precise prose and the pretty straightforward way in which the characters express themselves, this is so not a simple story.  And there are so many characters who feel 3-dimensional in this world, that I just can't believe this book didn't take 50 years to write!  Really my second impressions of this book let me take in how Melina tells the story, and how fantastic she is at spinning so many plates at once.

Another thing that stands out for me is the realism of the details.  I'm just going to point out the scene where Finnikin (and Trevanion!) goes off with some prostitutes.  It's just sex, and so matter of factly stated.  Why was this included when Melina could have painted Finnikin in a more heroically romantic way?  Because this is realistic.  And those touches of realism adds so much to the portraits of these characters  - where Evanjalin is hurt by his decision to go with some girl he doesn't know, but she doesn't pout over it - just throws it at him in a heated moment, immediately changing the subject.  But you know it rankled.  As it should.  And Finnikin has to grapple with his feelings for Evanjalin that is more than just physical need.  There's also the moments in the Exile camps when you feel the pain of these displaced people and you wonder what is the best place for them.  The scenes are brief overall but it's chilling and inspiring at the same time.  Because they have survived and are going to find a way home.

If you do feel overwhelmed though with all these characters and their individual stories as a first-time reader, I'd just recommend to stick with the story as things become clearer later on and emotional arcs start to coalesce into face-punching feels.  Not that there aren't enough major Feels moments already in the first part of this book.  Trevanion and Finnikin's reunion is a major one to me.  Evanjalin and Finnikin's contentious romance (!!)  And the moment when Evanjalin tells Trevanion about Beatriss (Bevanion 4eva! Thanks Paola!)  Also there's the introduction of the best hashtag motivator in the world:  #whatneedstobedone

"What have you done?" he asked hoarsely.
The look she gave him was pure anguish.
"What needs to be done!" (p75)

Just put that phrase up over your home or work desk space and stare at it whenever you don't feel like writing that blog post, review, or story.  It needs to be done folks! :)

If you would like, please comment with any of your thoughts on the first half of this book!
What do you think of the world building?
Any characters stand out or resonate with you?
Has it lived up at all to the ridiculous expectations our enthusiasm for the books has created?  (Sorry about that)

And if you are posting your own discussions/reaction posts you can link up to it here for all the other participants to read!  For a breakdown of what's been happening this past week for this event check out the links below:


Week 1 Discussion: Link Submission

Share this post: Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Email This Pin This Share on Google Plus Share on Tumblr
Scroll Up

7 comments:

  1. WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE

    ... has been my life motto since I read this book. Hahaha.

    Oh and you're welcome for Bevanion~ But YES, the prostitutes??! I mean I get that Finn is supposed to be portrayed as not your typical "innocent" character, but this seemed a bit much for me >< Have you noticed that Evanjalin has perfected the art of silently fuming over things, then waiting until the most opportune moment to finally say something when it will have the highest impact?? Girl is a professional. Seriously.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Definitely I find myself saying it at work when I don't particularly feel like doing something. It honors my previously unknown Lumateran roots. :D

      LOL, I have noticed how Evanjalin fumes better during this second read! I LOVE it!! I just start to feel sorry for Finnikin whenever he does something stupid! :D

      Delete
  2. I'm obviously a bit late answering the discussion questions, but I'm excited to join in :) I just started Finnikin last night and I'm already to the halfway point because I just couldn't put it down. Surprisingly, I do feel like it lived up to all your hype. I don't know if I was just in the mood for fantasy or if it's really that awesome, but I felt like it did epic really well without going over the top. Likewise, everything was exactly as it should be in a good fantasy novel without getting cliched. I did think the characters were very well fleshed out,

    I'm not sure how I feel about the Finnikin/Evanjalin dynamic. I would never be interested in a guy who could sleep with a prostitute after having met me, so I'm not sure how I feel about Evanjalin still seeming interested. It also bothers me a bit that Finnikin is so caught up with being in charge, something I feel is at least partially motivated by Evanjalin being a woman. However, I think how I feel about that will really depend on how things end up, because there are also flashes of Finnikin admiring her strength. As long as the book makes it clear at the end that he should respect her, I think I'll very much admire the author for tackling a topic so relevant today with many women earning as much or more than their husbands. Very interesting read so far!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh I'm so glad you are devouring this novel! :D And I think you are absolutely right about the fantasy and the character development! You make some very valid points about Finnikin and his error in judgement. I think it's difficult for Evanjalin as well, but I hope things are turned around enough for you in the end. It's something that I think the author does very well - making you understand and sympathize with characters you initially didn't warm up to. I will be so interested to read your final thoughts on the book!

      Delete
    2. " I don't know if I was just in the mood for fantasy or if it's really that awesome..."

      ... Nope, it really is that awesome~

      Also Finn can be a complete moron sometimes, agreed!!

      Delete
  3. I completely agree with you! I loved the realism of the story. I was so impressed by the prostitutes scene -- as odd as that sounds -- because it's real. If I were a guy who suffered like Finnikin did and I was given such a chance ... I'd probably take it. It wasn't like him and Evanjalin were in love yet or anything, and he is a man. A man that could die any day. I really respected the fact that Melina didn't try to hide sex from YA either. It's something that happens.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly! I'm glad that you agree because I think some people were put off by that, but I do love that these characters do things you might not like but you still love them because it's so human. And Melina gets extra awesome points for that in my book!

      Delete